Draft 1 of Grade 3: The Explication
On time, neat
|
Yes
20
|
Slovenly
10
|
No
0
|
|
Good, strong
attempt
|
Yes
40
|
Some effort visible
30
|
Slapped out a few
minutes ago
20
|
No
0
|
Two or three valid,
reliable, published, scholarly critics
|
Yes, with response
to their ideas cooking
20
|
One critic, with
some response
15
|
Unreliable critics
just googled up
10
|
No
0
|
Discussion
|
You have clear questions,
opinions, and a path
20
|
You have a vague
path and vague questions but some engagement
15
|
You have listlessly
fulfilled what’s required
10
|
It’s not clear you
have read the whole poem from your discussion
0
|